Washington · as of September 2026

The best luxury home agents in Bainbridge Island

12 agents who close Bainbridge Island's high end, ranked by what they sell for, how much of it is on record, and what their clients say afterward.

No. 1
M

Michele Schuler

Real Residential

5.0 · 79 reviews

Avg sale
$2.5M
Top sale
$4.4M
Closed
596
No. 2
J

Jen Pells

Windermere RE, Bainbridge Island, Inc.

5.0 · 106 reviews

Avg sale
$1.8M
Top sale
$3.0M
Closed
488
No. 3
D

Dennis Paige

Realogics Sotheby's International Realty

5.0 · 53 reviews

Avg sale
$1.7M
Top sale
$2.5M
Closed
588
No. 4
B

Barb McKenzie

Coldwell Banker BAIN

5.0 · 39 reviews

Avg sale
$1.7M
Top sale
$3.8M
Closed
531
No. 5
A

Arthur Mortell

Sotheby's International Real Estate

5.0 · 63 reviews

Avg sale
$1.5M
Top sale
$3.3M
Closed
706
No. 6
W

Windermere Bainbridge Island

Windermere Bainbridge Island

5.0 · 238 reviews

Avg sale
$1.1M
Top sale
$1.5M
Closed
2,333
No. 7
K

Kristi Nelson

Realogics Sotheby's Int'l Realty

5.0 · 28 reviews

Avg sale
$1.6M
Top sale
$2.4M
Closed
181
No. 8
C

Cheryl Mauer

Windermere Real Estate Bainbridge

5.0 · 33 reviews

Avg sale
$1.4M
Top sale
$2.1M
Closed
299
No. 9
F

Fitzpatrick and Co.

Compass

5.0 · 65 reviews

Avg sale
$1.3M
Top sale
$2.4M
Closed
288
No. 10
C

Claudia Powers

Realogics Sotheby's International Realty

5.0 · 28 reviews

Avg sale
$1.5M
Top sale
$2.5M
Closed
152
No. 11
D

Dana Fitzpatrick, MBA

Compass Real Estate

5.0 · 60 reviews

Avg sale
$1.3M
Top sale
$2.4M
Closed
247
No. 12
M

Mark Middleton

The Agency Bainbridge Island & The Agency Port Townsend

5.0 · 56 reviews

Avg sale
$1.0M
Top sale
$1.4M
Closed
708

Frequently Asked Questions — Bainbridge Island Real Estate