Arizona · as of September 2026

The best luxury home agents in Cave Creek

12 agents who close Cave Creek's high end, ranked by what they sell for, how much of it is on record, and what their clients say afterward.

No. 1
D

Don and Jenny Matheson

The Matheson Team, RE/MAX Fine Prop

5.0 · 193 reviews

Avg sale
$1.2M
Top sale
$2.1M
Closed
2,440
No. 2
D

Darren Tackett

The Tackett Team powered by eXp Realty

5.0 · 365 reviews

Avg sale
$1.1M
Top sale
$2.0M
Closed
2,161
No. 3
N

Nicole Humphrey

APEX Residential

5.0 · 65 reviews

Avg sale
$1.3M
Top sale
$3.6M
Closed
297
No. 4
I

Iconic Home Team

EXP Realty

5.0 · 1006 reviews

Avg sale
$819K
Top sale
$1.2M
Closed
3,026
No. 5
S

Sharon Wisniewski

APEX Residential

5.0 · 91 reviews

Avg sale
$1.0M
Top sale
$2.6M
Closed
308
No. 6
D

David Crozier

Russ Lyon Sotheby's International Reality

5.0 · 76 reviews

Avg sale
$1.0M
Top sale
$2.2M
Closed
250
No. 7
C

Cari Dandy

Russ Lyon Sotheby's Int'l Realty

5.0 · 68 reviews

Avg sale
$947K
Top sale
$1.6M
Closed
462
No. 8
T

Tracy Fitzgerald

The Noble Agency Top 1%

5.0 · 94 reviews

Avg sale
$951K
Top sale
$2.0M
Closed
366
No. 9
R

RTT Home Group

RE/MAX Fine Properties

5.0 · 440 reviews

Avg sale
$689K
Top sale
$940K
Closed
1,393
No. 10
S

Shawn Rogers

West USA Realty - MisterRogersHomes

5.0 · 1197 reviews

Avg sale
$638K
Top sale
$940K
Closed
1,779
No. 11
R

Rachel Russo

Rachel Russo Homesmart

5.0 · 111 reviews

Avg sale
$881K
Top sale
$1.8M
Closed
301
No. 12
L

Lisa Lanke

EXP Realty

5.0 · 149 reviews

Avg sale
$966K
Top sale
$1.4M
Closed
147

Frequently Asked Questions — Cave Creek Real Estate