Hawaii · as of September 2026

The best luxury home agents in Paia

12 agents who close Paia's high end, ranked by what they sell for, how much of it is on record, and what their clients say afterward.

No. 1
B

Brad MacArthur

Hawaii Life

5.0 · 134 reviews

Avg sale
$3.3M
Top sale
$8.3M
Closed
554
No. 2
W

William Jalbert

The Maui Real Estate Team, Inc.

5.0 · 58 reviews

Avg sale
$3.2M
Top sale
$9.9M
Closed
514
No. 3
V

Villa Group

Coldwell Banker Island Properties

5.0 · 48 reviews

Avg sale
$2.6M
Top sale
$4.6M
Closed
303
No. 4
B

Berkshire Hathaway HI's Most Trusted

Berkshire Hathaway Hawai'i Island Properties

5.0 · 165 reviews

Avg sale
$1.8M
Top sale
$6.4M
Closed
969
No. 5
C

Christopher Barca

Compass

5.0 · 66 reviews

Avg sale
$2.4M
Top sale
$4.9M
Closed
212
No. 6
D

Dave Futch

Compass

5.0 · 90 reviews

Avg sale
$2.0M
Top sale
$5.6M
Closed
309
No. 7
D

Dano Sayles

Coldwell Banker Island Properties

5.0 · 102 reviews

Avg sale
$1.1M
Top sale
$3.0M
Closed
1,059
No. 8
S

Sara M Fox

Keller Williams Realty Maui

4.9 · 117 reviews

Avg sale
$1.4M
Top sale
$2.4M
Closed
219
No. 9
T

Todd Hudson

THE 808 TEAM @ Keller Williams Realty Maui

5.0 · 151 reviews

Avg sale
$1.0M
Top sale
$1.5M
Closed
675
No. 10
H

Hawaii Life Oahu

Hawaii Life Real Estate Brokers

5.0 · 853 reviews

Avg sale
$743K
Top sale
$1.2M
Closed
3,970
No. 11
M

Max Blair

Max Blair

5.0 · 85 reviews

Avg sale
$1.2M
Top sale
$3.0M
Closed
314
No. 12
A

Alana Rucynski Lydia Pedro

Hawaii Life Real Estate

5.0 · 97 reviews

Avg sale
$963K
Top sale
$2.4M
Closed
606

Frequently Asked Questions — Paia Real Estate